“In reality there are no separate events. Life moves along like water,
it's all connected to the source of the river is connected to the mouth
and the ocean.”
-- Alan Watts, The Essential Alan Watts
"It’s not impermanence per se, or even knowing we’re going to die, that
is the cause of our suffering, the Buddha taught. Rather, it’s our
resistance
to the fundamental uncertainty of our situation."
All
I could do was grin that morning.
Eight of us
had gathered for Monday Morning Mindfulness at Community Yoga and Wellness Center that day seven years ago to meditate and then explore the second slogan of the Lojong Trainings: "Regard all dharmas (i.e. everything) as dreams."
I had been facilitating this weekly sitting group each Monday for two years by then. At that point, the Heart Council Practice had not evolved to become a central focus for the band of irregular regulars who showed up each week.
MMM could get pretty wild and crazy.
Although I made the effort to give each person in the Mindfulness Circle the chance to check in on their life and practice each week after we shared periods of sitting and walking meditation, an energetic discussion would often emerge. I had to keep an eye on the clock, and "facilitate" some interesting transitions to keep us "on track." It reminded me a bit of my stint as a high school social studies teacher back in the 1970's leading somewhat "guided' discussions.
Being the human beings we are, sometimes the discussions in the Circle could get quite heated and contentious. Occasionally, I'd get "hooked," loose track of my role -- add fuel to the fire. One morning, seeing that things were out of control, the one of the Irregular Regulars had belly flopped from her zafu and stretched out prone on the polished wooden floor of the studio to ring my bell. I loved it.
The Promise of Paradox
Thankfully, the morning that the eight of us began our dive into"Regard all dharmas as dreams" didn't require any such belly flop. A few months prior to that, I had been encouraged by one of the more regular of the Irregular Regulars to lead a plunge into the 59 Lojong slogans. Knowing that I was an inveterate bookworm/spiritual geek, she had my number. I dutifully spent months reading all the commentaries I could get my hands on, and had incorporated the slogans and Tonglen meditation into my daily life and practice.
I had just opened the discussion by briefly sharing my take on Lojong slogan two. Although a couple of folks in the Circle,
perhaps quite aware of the limitations, maybe even the inadvisability,
of placing so much of our emotional energy and collective
attention on words and discursive thought didn't participate, the rest
of us jumped right in.
Having studied and practiced Zen which has a long tradition of probing questions and dharma "combat," I marveled at what emerged. Although
all assembled, myself included, were essentially beginners in the study
of these particular Teachings, I imagine the energetic, sincere, often profound,
sometimes amusing, discussion that emerged could have been a
conversation among senior monks somewhere.